Whether you're shipping products to distribution centers, moving materials between facilities, or delivering orders to customers across the United States, you need a logistics partner that understands your requirements and can coordinate the right transportation solution.
But when comparing freight providers, you may come across two terms: asset based freight brokerage and traditional freight brokerage. They sound similar, and both help shippers arrange transportation, but their operating models are different.
A traditional freight brokerage primarily arranges shipments through third-party carriers. An asset based freight brokerage combines brokerage services with access to transportation assets, such as trucks and trailers, operated by its own organization or affiliated operations.
So, what does that difference mean for shippers? It can affect the transportation options available, how capacity is coordinated, and how a logistics provider approaches changing shipping requirements.
At Cargo Sharks, we believe understanding your freight partner's operating model is an important step toward making informed shipping decisions. After all, you wouldn't choose a vessel for an ocean crossing without knowing what it can carry. The same logic applies to freight transportation.
Let's break down the differences between asset based and traditional freight brokerage, explore the advantages of each model, and explain why the combination of transportation assets and brokerage capabilities deserves a closer look.
Table of Contents
- What Is a Traditional Freight Brokerage?
- What Is an Asset Based Freight Brokerage?
- Asset Based vs. Traditional Brokerage: Key Differences
- Benefits of an Asset Based Freight Brokerage
- When Does Each Brokerage Model Make Sense?
- How to Choose the Right Freight Brokerage
- Why Cargo Sharks Combines Brokerage with Transportation Resources
- Frequently Asked Questions
13 ft
What Is a Traditional Freight Brokerage?
A traditional freight brokerage connects businesses that need to ship goods with motor carriers that transport those goods. Rather than operating its own fleet as its primary transportation model, a traditional brokerage arranges shipments through third-party carriers within its network.
The broker helps coordinate the transportation process, which may include finding available capacity, negotiating rates, arranging pickups and deliveries, communicating shipment updates, and managing transportation documentation.
For shippers, this model provides access to a network of carriers without requiring them to establish and manage every carrier relationship independently.
For example, imagine a distributor needs to move several truckloads of products from Illinois to Georgia. A traditional freight broker can look for qualified carriers with suitable equipment and available capacity for those lanes, then coordinate the shipments with the selected providers.
The broker acts as the connection between the shipper and the carrier, helping organize the movement of freight from origin to destination.
How Traditional Freight Brokerage Works
The process generally follows a few steps:
- A shipper provides the shipment details, including pickup and delivery locations, freight characteristics, equipment requirements, and timing.
- The broker searches its carrier network for suitable transportation capacity.
- A carrier is selected and the shipment is arranged.
- The broker coordinates communication and shipment updates.
- Delivery is completed and the required documentation is collected.
The exact process varies by provider, but the objective remains the same: connect the shipment with appropriate transportation capacity and coordinate the details.
A traditional brokerage can offer access to an extensive carrier network, which may be particularly useful for businesses shipping across multiple regions or handling different types of freight.
25 ft
What Is an Asset Based Freight Brokerage?
An asset based freight brokerage combines freight brokerage services with access to transportation assets, such as trucks and trailers, operated by its own organization or affiliated carrier operations.
Instead of relying exclusively on third-party carriers, this model brings together transportation resources and brokerage capabilities. The provider can coordinate shipments using its own or affiliated transportation resources when suitable, while also drawing on outside carriers to support additional lanes, equipment needs, or shipment volumes.
For shippers, this combination can create a broader range of transportation options.
Consider the same distributor shipping from Illinois to Georgia. An asset based freight brokerage may evaluate available capacity within its transportation operations while also considering qualified third-party carriers. The appropriate solution depends on the shipment's requirements, available equipment, timing, and current capacity.
The key advantage is having different avenues to explore when arranging freight.
How Asset Based Freight Brokerage Works
The process begins much like a traditional brokerage arrangement:
- The shipper provides shipment details and transportation requirements.
- The brokerage evaluates suitable options through its transportation resources and carrier network.
- The appropriate transportation provider is selected based on the shipment's needs and available capacity.
- The shipment is coordinated, with communication and tracking handled according to the provider's procedures.
- Delivery documentation and other required records are collected.
The difference is the combination of brokerage operations and access to transportation assets.
This can give the provider a direct operational perspective on certain shipments while retaining the flexibility to arrange transportation through outside carriers when needed.
An asset based brokerage is not simply a company with trucks. It is a logistics model that combines transportation resources with the ability to coordinate freight across a wider network.
38 ft
Asset Based vs. Traditional Brokerage: Key Differences
Both models help shippers arrange transportation, but their resources and operating structures differ.
The following comparison highlights the main distinctions.
| Feature | Traditional freight brokerage | Asset based freight brokerage |
|---|---|---|
| Primary operating model | Arranges transportation through third-party carriers | Combines brokerage services with access to transportation assets |
| Transportation resources | Relies on its carrier network | Can use its own or affiliated resources and third-party carriers |
| Capacity options | Based on available carrier network capacity | May offer additional options through combined transportation resources |
| Equipment availability | Depends on participating carriers | Depends on asset availability and the broader carrier network |
| Shipment coordination | Managed through brokerage operations | Can coordinate shipments across asset and brokerage operations |
| Geographic reach | Depends on carrier network coverage | Depends on transportation resources and carrier network coverage |
| Freight types | Depends on the carrier network and brokerage capabilities | Depends on available assets, affiliated resources, and carrier network |
| Pricing | Influenced by lane, capacity, equipment, and market conditions | Influenced by lane, capacity, equipment, market conditions, and the transportation option selected |
Neither model automatically determines the quality of service. Communication, operational processes, carrier qualification, and the provider's ability to meet your shipping requirements remain important.
However, the combination of transportation assets and brokerage services gives asset based brokerages another way to approach capacity planning and shipment coordination.
For shippers, the practical question is how well the provider's resources align with their freight requirements.
51 ft
Benefits of an Asset Based Freight Brokerage
An asset based freight brokerage can offer several advantages to businesses seeking transportation solutions that combine direct access to assets with a broader carrier network.
1. Access to Multiple Sources of Capacity
One of the main benefits is the ability to explore transportation options through both asset operations and third-party carriers.
This can be particularly helpful when shipment volumes fluctuate, new orders arrive unexpectedly, or certain lanes become more difficult to cover.
For example, a shipper may have a regular schedule of truckloads but need additional capacity during a seasonal peak. An asset based brokerage can evaluate available transportation resources alongside its carrier network to identify suitable options.
Actual availability depends on the lane, equipment, schedule, and market conditions, but having multiple avenues to explore can support more flexible planning.
2. A Broader Operational Perspective
Combining transportation assets with brokerage services can provide insight into both the practical requirements of moving freight and the process of arranging capacity across a network.
This perspective can help inform discussions about equipment, pickup schedules, delivery requirements, and shipment planning.
For shippers, working with a partner that understands these operational details can make it easier to communicate requirements and evaluate transportation options.
3. Flexible Freight Coordination
Businesses rarely ship the same volume to the same destinations under identical conditions every week.
An asset based brokerage can draw on its transportation resources and carrier relationships to coordinate changing requirements, subject to availability.
This flexibility can be useful for manufacturers, distributors, and retailers managing seasonal demand, new customers, or changing shipping schedules.
4. Support for Different Equipment Requirements
Depending on its network and capabilities, an asset based brokerage may coordinate dry van, refrigerated, flatbed, expedited, and less-than-truckload shipments.
This can help shippers manage different transportation needs through a single logistics relationship, where the provider has the appropriate resources and service coverage.
It is always worth confirming equipment availability and handling requirements for individual shipments.
5. A Potentially More Integrated Logistics Relationship
An asset based brokerage can bring together transportation resources, brokerage coordination, and shipment management within a combined operating model.
For shippers, this may create opportunities to establish consistent processes for recurring lanes, shipment updates, documentation, and communication.
The value comes from how well those functions work together. A strong logistics partner should understand your requirements, communicate clearly, and coordinate transportation in a way that supports your business.
63 ft
When Does Each Brokerage Model Make Sense?
The right choice depends on your shipping requirements, the provider's capabilities, and the type of relationship you want to establish.
When a Traditional Freight Brokerage May Be a Good Fit
A traditional brokerage may suit businesses that want access to a broad network of third-party carriers without needing a provider with its own or affiliated transportation assets.
This can be useful when shipping across numerous regions, sourcing specialized capacity, or working with a broker that has established experience with particular lanes or freight types.
The size and quality of the carrier network, along with communication and service processes, are important factors when evaluating this model.
When an Asset Based Freight Brokerage May Be a Good Fit
An asset based brokerage may be especially appealing to shippers who value a combination of transportation assets and brokerage services.
This model can be useful for businesses that:
- Ship recurring truckloads and want to explore different capacity options.
- Experience seasonal changes or fluctuations in shipment volume.
- Need support across multiple lanes or equipment types.
- Prefer working with a logistics partner that combines transportation resources with brokerage coordination.
- Want a partner that can discuss both asset availability and outside carrier options when planning shipments.
For example, a distributor with regular shipments between the Midwest and the Southeast may benefit from a partner that can evaluate available transportation resources alongside its wider carrier network.
The most important consideration is whether the provider can support your actual shipping requirements. An asset based model offers a combination of resources, but specific capabilities should always be confirmed.
76 ft
How to Choose the Right Freight Brokerage
Understanding the difference between asset based and traditional brokerage is only the first step. You also need to evaluate the provider that will be handling your freight.
Here are five factors worth considering.
Evaluate the Transportation Network
Ask which lanes the provider regularly serves, what equipment it can access, and how it handles shipments outside its primary operating areas.
For asset based brokerages, it is useful to understand which transportation resources are available directly and when third-party carriers may be used.
Review Safety and Carrier Qualification Practices
Ask how the provider evaluates carriers, verifies applicable operating authority and insurance, and manages carrier compliance.
For additional information on motor carriers, consult the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's SAFER System.
Understand Communication and Shipment Visibility
Find out how pickup and delivery updates are provided, who manages your shipments, and how changes are communicated.
A clear process for tracking, escalation, and documentation helps your team stay informed throughout the transportation process.
Compare Pricing and Service
Consider the complete transportation cost, including applicable accessorial charges, rather than focusing exclusively on the initial quote.
Ask how detention, layover, re-delivery, and other additional charges are handled. Compare the pricing structure alongside the provider's capabilities and service expectations.
Consider Your Future Shipping Needs
Your freight requirements may change as your business expands. Look for a provider that understands your current lanes and volumes and can discuss how it might support future needs.
A good logistics relationship should be based on clear expectations, suitable transportation resources, and a shared understanding of what your business requires.
The right partner is not necessarily the one with the biggest fleet or the largest carrier list. It is the one whose capabilities and processes align with your freight operation.
88 ft
Why Cargo Sharks Combines Brokerage with Transportation Resources
At Cargo Sharks, we believe shippers benefit from understanding not just where their freight is going, but also how their transportation partner approaches the journey.
Established in 2020 and based in Oak Lawn, Illinois, Cargo Sharks provides freight brokerage services backed by a broader transportation organization with more than 800 trucks and over 1,000 trailers across its combined operations.
Our capabilities include dry van, refrigerated (reefer), flatbed, expedited, and less-than-truckload (LTL) freight solutions, allowing us to support a range of transportation requirements through appropriate resources.
By combining brokerage services with access to transportation assets and a broader carrier network, we can explore different options when coordinating shipments.
We understand that every load has its own requirements. Some shipments call for routine planning and predictable schedules; others need additional coordination, specialized equipment, or a different approach to capacity.
Our focus is on understanding those requirements, communicating clearly, and helping customers identify suitable freight transportation solutions.
And because freight transportation rarely follows a perfectly straight line, having a logistics partner that knows how to work through changing requirements can make a real difference.
At Cargo Sharks, we believe in practical solutions, straightforward communication, and no fishy business.
Looking for a freight partner that understands your shipping needs?
Contact Cargo Sharks to discuss your freight requirements and explore how our asset based brokerage capabilities can support your business.
Let's find the right route for your freight.
101 ft
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the difference between asset based and traditional freight brokerage?
A traditional freight brokerage primarily arranges transportation through third-party carriers. An asset based freight brokerage combines brokerage services with access to transportation assets operated by its own organization or affiliated operations. Both arrange freight, but their transportation resources and operating structures differ.
2. Is an asset based freight brokerage a carrier or a broker?
An asset based freight brokerage combines brokerage capabilities with access to transportation assets. The specific legal and operating structure varies by company. Depending on the arrangement, a shipment may be handled through an affiliated or owned carrier operation or arranged with an independent third-party carrier.
3. Why do shippers choose an asset based freight brokerage?
Shippers may value the combination of transportation assets and brokerage services because it provides additional options for evaluating capacity, coordinating shipments, and responding to changing freight requirements. The specific benefits depend on the provider's network, available equipment, and operating processes.
4. Are asset based freight brokerages more expensive than traditional brokers?
Not necessarily. Rates depend on factors such as the shipping lane, freight characteristics, equipment requirements, available capacity, and market conditions. Shippers should compare total transportation costs and the services included in each quote when evaluating providers.
5. Can an asset based freight brokerage use third-party carriers?
Yes. An asset based freight brokerage can arrange shipments through third-party carriers as well as use its own or affiliated transportation resources, depending on its operating structure and the shipment's requirements.
This combination can provide flexibility when evaluating available capacity.
6. What types of freight can an asset based brokerage handle?
Depending on its transportation resources and carrier network, an asset based brokerage may coordinate dry van, refrigerated, flatbed, expedited, and less-than-truckload freight. Shippers should confirm the provider's equipment availability, geographic coverage, and handling capabilities for their specific shipments.
7. How do I choose between an asset based brokerage and a traditional freight broker?
Start by evaluating your shipping lanes, freight types, shipment volumes, and service requirements. Then compare each provider's transportation network, equipment options, communication processes, carrier qualification practices, and pricing. An asset based brokerage may be a strong fit if you value access to transportation assets alongside broader brokerage capabilities.
